Stompboxes .. What is best.. XLR or Jack plugs?

Workshop Blog: Choosing Between XLR and Jack Connections for Stompboxes

Hello, I'm Peter Sesselmann, and welcome to our workshop blog. Today, I'm joined by Alex Yates, who is responsible for creating many of the products we offer. We're going to tackle a common question that comes up frequently in emails and discussions – which is better, the XLR or Jack model for stompboxes? Let's dive into it together.

Exploring the Differences: XLR vs. Jack: As you can see, here's an XLR puck and a Jack connection. The XLR features a plug like this, while the Jack connection resembles a standard guitar jack. So, what's the difference, Alex?

Application and Practicality: Alex: It's not necessarily about which is better, but rather where you're going to plug it in and the practicality of the situation. The electronic differences between XLR and Jack connections have been discussed extensively online, and there are various opinions on which one is superior. In terms of sound quality, with a good-quality cable, any differences are subtle and likely negligible.

XLR for Stage Performances: Peter: If you're performing on large stages with snakes or breakout boxes, the XLR might be more convenient. XLR connectors are common in such setups, and it eliminates the need for a separate DI box when connecting to a sound system.

Jack for Home Use: Alex: On the other hand, if you're playing at home with a small bass or practice amp, using a Jack connection might be more practical. You wouldn't need to drag out a whole PA system for practice.

Sound Difference – Practical vs. Theoretical: Peter: When it comes to the sound difference, in the case of stompboxes like these, the variation is either minimal or nonexistent. Any difference you perceive might actually be due to the preamp in the PA system, as they often have different circuits for XLR and Jack inputs.

Conclusion: Practicality Matters: In summary, both XLR and Jack connections are good systems. The choice between them depends on your specific setup and application. If you're asking for our opinion, we tend to find Jack connections a bit more convenient, especially for personal use.

Jack vs. XLR Reliability: Alex: From my experience, Jack plugs falling out is less common than XLR plugs. Inside XLR plugs, there are tiny sleeve springs that might lose tightness over time, leading to connectivity issues.

Closing Thoughts: Peter: To wrap it up, in most scenarios, there's no significant sound difference between XLR and Jack connections for stompboxes. It boils down to your personal preference and your specific playing environment.

Alex: That's right. What works best for you is the key consideration.

Peter: Thank you for tuning in to our workshop blog. If you have questions or topics you'd like us to cover, feel free to drop us a line or an email. And don't forget to subscribe and hit the notification bell to receive updates. Have a great day, and catch you next time!

And that's a wrap for our discussion on XLR and Jack connections for stompboxes. Remember, the choice between the two depends on your specific needs and playing environment. Enjoy your musical journey, and until next time, keep experimenting and grooving! Cheers!

Back to blog